Each theme has the first player eliminated removed in a special way.

Army Of Darkness Ash and Sam: Max reads the Necronomicon wrong. It then flies around the room and devours the character who busted.

Borderlands 2 Ash: GLaDos says Ashley Williams has been eliminated or he will be in a minute. Steve (the character on the cover of Borderlands and Borderlands 2) drops down on the stage and opens fire with a confetti rocket. Ash gets knocked on the ground. Ash complains that if they wanted him to leave they could have just asked.

Borderlands 2 Brock: Steve drops down and shoots Brock with the confetti cannon. Brock says to excuse him, and exits the screen. Steve can be heard saying a nervous "Heyooo" before the sounds of a pummeling are heard.

Borderlands 2 Claptrap: Claptrap imitates the demise of Jesse James telling Steve to do what he has to do. Steve shoots Claptrap with a confetti cannon and lets out a mournful "Heyoooo", which Claptrap dismisses as he gets up and calls Steve a drama queen.

Borderlands 2 Sam: Steve puts a hand on Sam's shoulder. Max growls and Sam says "You crack me up, Steve", then the three of them leave to hang out together.

Portal Ash and Sam: GLaDOS opens a portal underneath them and another on the wall in the back of the inventory.

Sam And Max 25th Brock: Max leaps on Brock's head and begins chewing on him. Brock does not take much notice other than showing mild annoyance.

Sam And Max 25th Sam: The time machine from Sam And Max: Season 2 appears, and another version of Sam and Max asks them to join them on an adventure.