To make a decent replica of the Converse All-Star Low shoes, enter the following under Shoe Creator (total cost: 975).

Shoe Template: Superstar Low (cost: 750)
Base Area: 2/29
Ankle Area: 2/19
Heel Area: 2/29
Laces Area: 1/19
Lace Trim Area: 2/29
Logo Area 1: 2/19
Logo Area 2: 2/29
Logo Area 3: 2/29
Sole Area: 1/19
Toe Area: 1/19
Tongue Area: 2/29
City: Any
City Color: 2/19

Note: This is how to make them black. To make them red, change the 2s to 4s. To make them dark blue, change the 2s to 13s. To make them light blue, change the 2s to 12s.