The table below shows how to unlock new teams that can be played as in the following modes: Pick Up, Season, Dingers (captains only, doesn't allow the All-Stars team captain) , and Play-Offs. Note: The All-Stars will not have your Story Mode player unless playing in Story Mode. Instead, it will have every single captain in the game (excluding Jimmy Knuckles and your story mode player) on the team.

Unlockable	How to unlock
All Other Teams	All other teams are unlocked upon starting the game.
The All-Stars	Beat all teams (besides The Bullies) in Story Mode.
The Bullies	Beat ALL teams in Story Mode.