Use the following trick to stop a penalty kick about 80% of the time. Move your goalkeeper to either the left or the right side of the goal (as far as you can move him). While the striker is running up, move the goalkeeper to the opposite side (of where you first moved) and dive low. About 80% of the time you will stop the kick. Use the Left Analog-stick to sidestep faster and get a better chance of saving the ball. Note: Sometimes the kick is too good to stop or he will not kick this way.