Use the following trick if you are having a hard time hitting homeruns with the Analog hitting system. It seems to work better if you do not use L1 and L2. Try to time the pitches. Start loading your swing with the Right Analog-stick when the pitcher is at full extension. If you make good contact, it will fly without the power swing. Only use L1 and R1 when you need a sacrifice fly or to do a hit and run. It is all about timing. Also, the Left Analog-stick is not used when trying to hit the ball.