Complete the indicated task in Story mode to unlock the corresponding character in Exhibition mode.

Abyss: Defeat Abyss.
Brother Ray: Defeat Team 3D.
Don West: Accumulate 250,000 Style Points.
Eric Young: After getting partnered with Eric Young, win a Tag Team match with him.
Jay Lethal: Defeat Jay Lethal.
Jeff Jarrett: Complete Story mode.
Kevin Nash: Defeat Kevin Nash.
Senshi: Accumulate 200,000 Style Points.
Sonjay Dutt: Defeat Sonjay Dutt.
Tomko: Win the Tomko and AJ Styles Tag Team match.