Win as either team of the rivalry to unlock the corresponding trophy.

Trophy	How to unlock
Apple Cup	University of Washington Huskies vs. Washington State University Cougars.
Battle of I-25 Trophy	New Mexico vs. New Mexico State.
Bayou Bucket	Houston Cougars vs. Rice Owls.
Beehive Boot	Utah vs. Brigham Young vs. Utah State vs. Weber State.
Bronze Boot	Colorado State University vs. University of Wyoming.
Commander in Chief	Army vs. Navy vs. Air Force.
Commonwealth Cup	University of Virginia Cavaliers vs. Virginia Tech Hokies.
Cy-Hawk Trophy	Iowa Hawkeyes vs. Iowa State Cyclones.
Floyd of Rosedale	University of Minnesota Gophers vs. Iowa Hawkeyes.
Fremont Cannon	Nevada Wolf Pack vs. UNLV Rebels.
Golden Boot	University of Arkansas Razorbacks vs. LSU Tigers.
Golden Egg Trophy	Ole Miss Rebels vs. Mississippi State.
Golden Hat	Texas Longhorns vs. Oklahoma Sooners.
Governor's Victory Bell	Minnesota vs. Penn State.
Illibuck	Ohio State Buckeyes vs. Illinois Fighting Illini.
Ireland Trophy	Boston College vs. Notre Dame.
Iron Skillet	South Methodist University Mustangs vs. Texas Christian University Horned Frogs.
Jeweled Shillelagh	Purdue vs. Nortre Dame.
Keg of Nails	Cincinnati Bearcats vs. Louisville Cardinals.
Land Grant Trophy	Penn State vs. Michigan State.
Little Brown Jug	Minnesota vs. University of Michigan.
Marching Drum	Kansas vs. Missouri.
Megaphone	Notre Dame vs. Michigan State.
Missouri-Nebraska Bell	Missouri vs. Nebraska.
ODK - FOY Sportsmanship Trophy	Alabama vs. Auburn.
Old Oaken Bucket	Indiana vs. Purdue.
Paul Buyan Trophy	Michigan vs. Michigan State.
Paul Buyan's Axe	Minnesota vs. Wisconsin.
Peace Pipe	Bowling Green vs. Toledo.
Purdue Cannon	Purdue vs. Illinois.
Seminole War Canoe	Florida vs. Miami.
Shellelagh Trophy	Nortre Dame vs. Purdue.
Silver Spade	New Mexico State vs. UTEP.
Stanford Axe	Cal vs. Stanford.
Telephone Trophy	Iowa State vs. Missouri.
Territorial Cup	Arizona vs. Arizona State.
Textile Bowl Trophy	Clemson vs. NC State.
Tiger Rag	LSU vs. Tulane.
Victory Bell	Miami University Red Hawks vs. Cincinati Bearcats.
Victory Bell	UCLA vs. USC.
Victory Bell	Missouri Tigers vs. Nebraska Cornhuskers.
Wagon Wheel	Akron vs. Kent State.
Williams Trophy	Rice vs. Tulsa.