Win the indicated PPV trophy in Season mode to unlock the corresponding wrestler for purchase at the shop.

Bam Bam Bigelow: Unforgiven Trophy
Bret Hart: Survivor Series Trophy
Cactus Jack: SummerSlam Trophy
Dude Love: SummerSlam Trophy
Hulk Hogan: WrestleMania Trophy
Jerry 'The King' Lawler: No Way Out Trophy
Jim 'The Anvil ' Neidhart: Survivor Series Trophy
Mankind: SummerSlam Trophy
Mr. Perfect: Backlash Trophy
Shane McMahon: Armageddon Trophy
Steve Austin: Royal Rumble Trophy
Stone Cold Steve Austin: Royal Rumble Trophy
Tazz: No Way Out Trophy
The Rock: WrestleMania Trophy