Use the following trick to unlock wrestlers that require a certain number of 1-on-1 wins in a particular program (for example, Finlay with a one match win on Smackdown or Zack Ryder with one win on WWE Superstars). After your win in the initial match (assuming you did not change the participants in the match), Vince McMahon may come in to say the match is not over. You will fight the man you can unlock. To be on the same side, assume that it is another 1-on-1 match, and defeat him.